Contrasting the Schlage Encode Plus vs Yale Assure Lock 2 can be difficult. Both offer a lot, from sophisticated security features to Apple HomeKit integration which provides convenient features like the Apple Home Key. I’ll explain how they differ in this article so you can choose the one that works best for your home.
What’s the Difference Between Schlage Encode Plus and Yale Assure Lock 2? (Quick Answer)
For those in a rush who only want the gist, here’s a brief explanation along with a full comparison table:
When it comes to Apple Home Key integration, the Schlage Encode Plus really excels. You can unlock your door with just a tap of your iPhone or Apple Watch. For those who are deeply invested in the Apple ecosystem and wish to simplify their smart home experience, this is ideal. It is also quite adaptable because it has built-in Wi-Fi and is compatible with both Google Assistant and Alexa.
In contrast, adaptability is key to the Yale Assure Lock 2. It can be configured to function with many smart home technologies, including Bluetooth, Wi-Fi, and Z-Wave, thanks to interchangeable modules.
It’s up to you to decide whether to get the Apple Home Key version or add extra capabilities like a fingerprint reader. The Yale Assure Lock 2 may be your best option if you’re looking for a small, multiplatform lock that is also customizable.
| Category | Schlage Encode Plus | Yale Assure Lock 2 | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Locking Mechanism | – ANSI/BHMA Grade 1 (highest security) – Deadbolt mechanism | – ANSI/BHMA Grade 2 – Deadbolt mechanism – IPX5 weatherproofing | Schlage Encode Plus |
| Tamper Detection | – Tamper alarm with real-time notifications via Schlage app or Apple HomeKit | – Tamper detection with notifications via Yale Access app – DoorSense technology for door status alerts | Yale Assure Lock 2 |
| Auto-Lock Feature | – Adjustable auto-lock via Schlage app or Apple HomeKit | – Adjustable auto-lock via Yale Access app | Tie |
| Geofencing | – Enabled through integrations with Apple HomeKit, Alexa, or IFTTT | – Enabled through integrations with Apple HomeKit, Alexa, or IFTTT | Tie |
| Access Methods | – Apple Home Key (iPhone/Apple Watch) – Physical key – Keypad – Schlage Home app | – Yale Access app – Keypad – Fingerprint scanner (Touch model) – Apple Home Key (Plus version) – Note: Must choose between fingerprint or Home Key models | Tie |
| Access Sharing | – Permanent or temporary codes via Schlage Home app – Works with Apple Home app – Supports voice unlock | – User codes with scheduling via Yale Access app – Integrates with multiple platforms for wider sharing – Ideal for Airbnb and rentals | Yale Assure Lock 2 |
| User Management | – Manage up to 100 codes – Activity log in Schlage Home app | – Manage up to 250 codes – Schedule time-based access – Ideal for rentals and service providers | Yale Assure Lock 2 |
| Wireless Protocols | – Built-in Wi-Fi and Bluetooth – No additional hub required | – Bluetooth by default – Optional Wi-Fi or Z-Wave modules (extra purchase) – Modular system allows customization | Schlage Encode Plus |
| Smart Home Integration | – Apple HomeKit (Apple Home Key) – Google Assistant – Amazon Alexa | – Apple HomeKit – Google Assistant – Amazon Alexa – Samsung SmartThings – Airbnb integration – Future Matter support (module in development) | Yale Assure Lock 2 |
| Voice Assistant Integration | – Compatible with Siri, Google Assistant, and Alexa | – Compatible with Siri, Google Assistant, and Alexa | Tie |
| Battery Life | – Approximately 6 months with Wi-Fi – Low-battery notifications – Apple Express Mode for dead iPhone | – Up to 1 year with Bluetooth only – Approximately 6 months with Wi-Fi module – Low-battery notifications via Yale Access app | Yale Assure Lock 2 |
| Emergency Power | – Unlock with Apple Home Key using reserve power on iPhone (Express Mode) | – Jump-start with a 9-volt battery if AA batteries fail | Yale Assure Lock 2 |
| Price | – Approximately $320 retail – Includes built-in Wi-Fi and Apple Home Key support | – Starts at $159.99 for base model – Touch model with fingerprint reader: $200 – Plus version with Apple Home Key: $289.99 – Wi-Fi module extra $80 | Yale Assure Lock 2 |
| Included Features | – All features included out of the box – No additional hardware needed – Grade 1 security certification | – Modular approach—add features as needed – Pay only for desired features – Grade 2 security certification | Schlage Encode Plus |
| Value for Money | – Better value for Apple ecosystem users needing all features immediately – Higher upfront cost but fully featured | – Lower initial cost – Flexibility to add features over time – More cost-effective for gradual smart home integration | Yale Assure Lock 2 |
Also Read:
Schlage Encode vs Schlage Encode Plus
Schlage Encode Plus vs. Yale Assure Lock 2: In-Depth Comparison
Now that we’ve covered the short answer, let’s look more closely at what actually distinguishes these two models, which are both a big contender in every list of the best smart locks. It’s important to focus on the specifics when using these technologies in daily life, and that’s what I’m all about.
This gives you the complete view, including security features and access management procedures. To begin, let us address security, which is among the most crucial elements.
Schlage Encode Plus vs Yale Assure Lock 2: Security Features
Security needs to be your first concern when it comes to smart locks. After all, the idea is to facilitate entry for you and your loved ones while keeping out intruders. While the Yale Assure Lock 2 and the Schlage Encode Plus approach security somewhat differently, they both take it seriously.
Locking Mechanism
The locking mechanism of smart locks is fundamental to the security they offer. Deadbolt mechanisms, which are well-known for their dependability and security, are a characteristic of both the Yale Assure Lock 2 and the Schlage Encode Plus.
Offering the highest security level for home locks, the Schlage Encode Plus has an ANSI/BHMA certification of Grade 1. With this accreditation, the lock is guaranteed to be extremely durable and has undergone testing to withstand intense physical force.
In practical terms, you can rest easy knowing that the lock will resist efforts at forced entry. Since you want something that can withstand a beating—not that I suggest testing that at home—I’ve always trusted Grade 1 locks.
Nonetheless, the Yale Assure Lock 2 has a Grade 2 ANSI/BHMA certification, which is just one level below Schlage’s Grade 1 rating, but still a very high security rating.
It cannot bear as much force as Schlage’s Grade 1 lock but nevertheless provides dependable security. But for the majority of household settings, Grade 2 is usually more than adequate.
Since I’ve used Yale locks myself, I can attest to their exceptional build quality and longevity. Moreover, the Assure Lock 2 boasts IPX5 weatherproofing, which means that it is made to withstand exposure to both high heat and water—an important feature if your door is exposed to the elements.
Tamper Detection
Tamper alarms are included with both the Yale Assure Lock 2 and the Schlage Encode Plus locks. If someone tries to tamper with the lock, the Schlage Encode Plus will sound an alarm. You’ll be informed in real time through the Schlage app or Apple HomeKit, so you’re informed even when you’re not at home.
Additionally, the Yale Assure Lock 2 has tamper detection. If tampering occurs, it will notify you through the Yale Access app when connected via Wi-Fi or a smart module. To further increase your peace of mind, the Yale Assure Lock 2 also has DoorSense technology, which alerts you when your door is locked and securely closed.
Auto-Lock Feature
The auto-lock feature of both locks secures the door automatically after a certain amount of time.
You can easily adjust how long the door remains unlocked with the Schlage Encode Plus by using the Schlage app or Apple HomeKit settings. This function is ideal for those of us who forget to lock up sometimes, because we’ve all had those moments when we wonder if the door is really secure.
The Yale Access app can be used to control the auto-lock feature of the Yale Assure Lock 2, which is also included. Users now have the freedom to adjust the security of their door according to their own preferences.
Geofencing Capabilities
Even though neither lock has built-in geofencing, the Yale Assure Lock 2 and Schlage Encode Plus can have it enabled thanks to connectivity with Apple HomeKit, Amazon Alexa, and other external services like IFTTT.
This makes it possible to automate locking or unlocking depending on your location, providing another level of convenience for people who are constantly on the go.
Schlage Encode Plus offers premier Grade 1 security, defying significant force. Yale Assure Lock 2 delivers robust Grade 2 protection, superior craftsmanship, and IPX5 weatherproofing.
Schlage Encode Plus vs Yale Assure Lock 2: User Access and Management
The Yale Assure Lock 2 and the Schlage Encode Plus both provide a variety of ways to limit who is able to enter your house. By allowing you to use your phone or smartwatch to share codes with friends, family, and service providers, these smart locks offer flexibility and convenience.
Each manufacturer’s approach to user access, sharing, and administration diverge significantly.
Access Methods
With the Schlage Encode Plus, you can unlock your door with just a tap of your iPhone or Apple Watch on the lock, thanks to its Apple Home Key connection. This hands-free method works best if you are already comfortable with the Apple ecosystem.
You have many options: in addition to Apple devices, you can use a regular physical key, a keypad, or the Schlage Home app to access the lock.
The Yale Assure Lock 2, on the other hand, offers a number of access possibilities depending on the model. You may unlock the door with the Yale Access app, a keypad, or, if you pick the Touch model, a fingerprint scanner.
Apple Home Key, like the Schlage Encode Plus, is supported by the Plus version. It is worth noting, however, that you will have to choose between the Home Key and the fingerprint reader because they are not included in the same model, which may be a drawback for those who want both.
Access Sharing
You can share access with both the Yale Assure Lock 2 and the Schlage Encode Plus, but they work in different ways. Using the Schlage Home app, you may generate either permanent or temporary codes with the Schlage Encode Plus.
The Apple Home app enables users of Apple HomeKit to share access and utilize the Apple Home Key functionality. Schlage can be unlocked using a voice match or PIN, but it also functions with Google Assistant and Amazon Alexa.
With user codes generated via the Yale Access app, the Yale Assure Lock 2 provides more versatile functionality. You may plan times for particular codes, just like with Encode Plus. This is great for service providers or vacation rentals like Airbnb.
Yale’s integrations with Google Assistant, Amazon Alexa, Apple HomeKit, and other platforms provide a wider range of interoperability for smart home installations.
User Management
If more than one person has access to your home, user management is essential. You can use the Schlage Home app to manage up to 100 different codes if you have the Schlage Encode Plus. You can also view who is coming and going from the residence at any given time with the app’s activity log.
If you would rather handle everything with Apple HomeKit, you’ll be restricted to the user management options Apple provides, which might not be as adaptable as the Schlage app.
Compared to Schlage, the Yale Assure Lock 2 has a far larger user code management capacity—up to 250. You may quickly add, remove, or change access codes with the Yale Access app. If you need to offer temporary access for specified periods or are in charge of managing short-term rentals, the schedule option for user codes is very helpful for arranging time-based access, increasing its versatility.
Schlage Encode Plus exemplifies flawless Apple Home Key integration. Yale Assure Lock 2 is a sleek, customizable smart lock with modular options and optional Apple Home Key functionality.
Schlage Encode Plus vs Yale Assure Lock 2: Connectivity and Compatibility
Connectivity and compatibility are important considerations when it comes to smart home technology. The easier the operation of your whole smart home system, the more possibilities you have for integrating your lock with other gadgets.
Although the Yale Assure Lock 2 and Schlage Encode Plus are both made to work with different smart home systems, their degrees of compatibility and connectivity vary based on your demands. Let’s see how they differ in this regard.
Wireless Protocols
The Schlage Encode Plus comes with built-in Wi-Fi, so no additional hub or bridge is needed to connect it to your home network, unlike other devices. This makes installation and setup easier for people who would rather not use extra devices.
When connected, the Schlage Home app allows you to regulate user codes, keep an eye on the lock’s condition, and lock or unlock the door from anywhere. Furthermore, it supports Bluetooth, which helps prolong battery life when you’re nearby and don’t need the Wi-Fi connection.
Conversely, the Yale Assure Lock 2 provides greater versatility because of its interchangeable modules. It has Bluetooth right out of the box, which is ideal for local control with the Yale Access app. However, one of Yale’s connectivity modules is required if you need to link the lock with additional platforms or operate it remotely.
The most often used is the Wi-Fi module, which enables interaction with various smart home systems like Apple HomeKit, Google Assistant, and Alexa, as well as remote control.
There is also a Z-Wave module for users of Z-Wave systems (such as Samsung SmartThings or Ring Alarm). You have more alternatives with this modular system, but if you want to go beyond basic Bluetooth capabilities, you will need to make an additional purchase.
Schlage Encode Plus flaunts integrated Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, eliminating the need for ancillary devices. Conversely, Yale Assure Lock 2 offers Bluetooth but requires additional modules for Wi-Fi, Z-Wave, or remote orchestration.
Smart Home Integration
Numerous smart home systems seamlessly interact with the Schlage Encode Plus. Its most notable features are that it supports Apple Home Key and is fully compatible with Apple HomeKit, which lets you unlock the door with just a tap on your iPhone or Apple Watch. If you’re an enthusiast of the Apple ecosystem, this feature is especially enticing.
You can use voice commands to operate Schlage’s lock or integrate it into your smart home routines, because it is compatible with Google Assistant and Amazon Alexa. Schlage offers you a plethora of connecting options, regardless of your preferred ecosystem.
Additionally, you can check out this page, it provides every smart home platform supported by Schlage Encode Plus:
https://www.schlage.com/en/home/smart-locks/schlage-encode-plus-works-with.html
When it comes to smart home connection, the Yale Assure Lock 2 is incredibly versatile. You can choose to connect with Google Assistant, Amazon Alexa, Samsung SmartThings, Apple HomeKit, or Google Home by adding the appropriate module. Additionally, it is compatible with Airbnb, which makes it perfect for people who rent out their homes or other properties.
Compared to Schlage, the lock can be integrated with a broader variety of smart home settings thanks to the Z-Wave module. Although it is still under development, Yale also intends to produce a Matter module that will enable the lock to work with the recently introduced Matter smart home standard.
When it comes to interoperability, the Yale Assure Lock 2 gives more options if you’re not limited to the Apple environment.
Voice Assistant Integration
Both locks are equipped to work with the most widely used voice control systems. Simply use voice commands to lock or unlock your door with the Schlage Encode Plus since it integrates smoothly with Google Assistant, Amazon Alexa, and Apple’s Siri.
Voice control is straightforward to use and intuitive, whether you’re asking Alexa to lock the door as you leave or using Siri on your iPhone.
The voice assistant integration of the Yale Assure Lock 2 is comparable. You can control the lock using Siri, Google Assistant, or Alexa, depending on the module you install.
Although voice control is simple, I discovered that Yale’s solution provides a little bit more versatility, particularly when paired with Z-Wave and other smart home devices.
That being said, you can easily secure your home without lifting a finger with both locks because they let you integrate voice commands into your regular activities.
Schlage Encode Plus vs Yale Assure Lock 2: Battery Life and Power Options
The battery life of smart locks is quite important. Ultimately, the last thing you want is for your lock to die at an awkward hour.
The Yale Assure Lock 2 and the Schlage Encode Plus both run on batteries, but they handle it differently, and depending on how much maintenance you can handle, their power options may influence your choice.
Schlage Encode Plus: Battery Life
Four AA batteries, which are widely available and somewhat inexpensive to replace, power the Schlage Encode Plus.
The lock uses more energy than some other smart locks because it has built-in Wi-Fi, so you’ll probably need to replace the batteries more frequently—every six months or so, depending on usage. The good news is that you can change the batteries before they die because the Schlage Home app notifies you when they are getting low.
On the other hand, the lock may save energy by switching from Wi-Fi to Bluetooth when you utilize its Bluetooth features in close proximity to the door. This helps prolong the battery life.
Compared to locks that use less power-hungry wireless protocols, I’ve found that although the built-in Wi-Fi is incredibly convenient for remote access, it does require more frequent battery changes.
Support for Apple’s Express Mode is one of the Schlage Encode Plus’s special features. Apple Home Key is a lifesaver in case your phone dies unexpectedly because it allows you to unlock the door using the reserve power on your iPhone even if the battery is entirely drained.
Yale Assure Lock 2: Battery Life
Although the Yale Assure Lock 2 also runs on four AA batteries, its battery life is often greater since, unless you add the extra Wi-Fi module, it operates over Bluetooth by default. You’ll probably obtain longer battery life if you stick with local control because Bluetooth uses less power than Wi-Fi.
With normal use, Yale estimates the battery life for the Bluetooth-only device to be approximately a year; however, the addition of a Wi-Fi module shortens that estimate to about six months, which is more in line with what Schlage offers.
The ability to jump-start the lock with a 9-volt battery in the event that the AA batteries fail and you are locked out is a useful feature of the Yale Assure Lock 2. This is an easy and practical fix, especially if you forget to change the batteries and don’t have quick access to a backup pair.
To temporarily power up the lock and have enough juice to unlock the door and change the batteries, simply place the correct 9-volt battery between its contacts on the bottom.
Similar to the Schlage, the Yale Access app notifies you when the battery is low, allowing you to replace the batteries well before they die. You don’t have to rely solely on alerts because the app lets you monitor the battery status at any moment.
Schlage Encode Plus vs Yale Assure Lock 2: Price and Value
After discussing the salient characteristics of the Yale Assure Lock 2 and Schlage Encode Plus, let’s move on to the one factor that can actually sway your choice: cost.
Depending on your needs and preferences, these locks offer differing value at different price points, despite having amazing features and protection. Which one, then, is better value for the money?
Schlage Encode Plus: Price and What You Get
At roughly $320 at retail, the Schlage Encode Plus is priced higher than other smart locks. But for that money, especially if you’re heavily invested in the Apple ecosystem, you’re getting a lot of premium features.
With integrated Wi-Fi, support for Google Assistant and Amazon Alexa, and integration with Apple Home Key, you’re effectively getting a lock that functions directly out of the box without the need for additional hardware or modules. Because you won’t need to pay more for add-ons to integrate the lock into your smart home, the higher price is more reasonable.
The Schlage Encode Plus is well worth the money for anyone who appreciates ease of use and smooth integration with Apple products.
Its value is increased by the special capability of being able to unlock your door with a simple tap of your iPhone or Apple Watch—even if your phone is dead. You also get superior physical protection for your home with the Grade 1 ANSI/BHMA security certification.
Yale Assure Lock 2: Price and Flexibility
Because it comes in several models with different characteristics, the Yale Assure Lock 2 offers a little more flexible pricing structure. A version with a physical keypad is the base model, which starts at about $159.99.
The cost rises as you add more advanced capabilities. For instance, the Yale Assure Lock 2 Plus with Apple Home Key costs approximately $289.99, while the Assure Lock 2 Touch with a fingerprint reader costs roughly $200. An extra $80 will be charged if a Wi-Fi module is added.
Even though this modular strategy may appear more intricate, it enables you to only pay for the items that you genuinely require. Choosing the base model or adding only the features you need, like Wi-Fi or Z-Wave compatibility for connection with Google Home or Amazon Alexa, can help you save money if you’re not part of the Apple ecosystem.
Furthermore, although not as high as Schlage’s Grade 1, the Yale Assure Lock 2 has a strong Grade 2 ANSI/BHMA certification that is nevertheless dependable for the majority of households.
The Yale Assure Lock 2’s customization features make it a desirable choice for those who wish to gradually expand their smart home setup without having to pay upfront for features they might not need right away.
Is Schlage or Yale Better in Terms of Value?
Because of its modular design and reduced initial cost, the Yale Assure Lock 2 is the best option when it comes to sheer value. If you don’t need all the premium features right now, you can acquire a good smart lock for a lot less.
The Yale Assure Lock 2 is an appealing, affordable choice if you intend to gradually expand your smart home setup because it allows you to add modules as you go.
But the Schlage Encode Plus is a formidable competitor if you’re looking for an elegant, all-in-one solution that provides excellent security and integrates flawlessly with Apple devices. Even though it costs more upfront, Apple users can leverage the included Wi-Fi and Home Key integration to make it a high-performing smart lock that works without any additional parts.
Your decision will depend on the features that are most essential to you and how deeply you want to integrate your smart lock into the ecosystem of your house. Price ranges from $160 to $320.
While both locks provide strong security and useful features, the Schlage Encode Plus delivers smooth operation right out of the box, and the Yale Assure Lock 2 offers greater versatility.
Conclusion
Your individual needs will determine which of the Yale Assure Lock 2 and Schlage Encode Plus is best for you, this means that the winner of this Schlage Encode Plus vs Yale Assure Lock 2 depends on you. The Schlage Encode Plus is a high-end choice if you want integrated Wi-Fi and seamless Apple Home Key integration. The Yale Assure Lock 2 is a great option for added versatility and affordable upgrades because of its modular features.
FAQs
Does the Schlage Encode Plus work without Wi-Fi?
Actually, the Schlage Encode Plus is equipped with both Bluetooth and Wi-Fi, enabling local control even in the absence of Wi-Fi. However, internet access is necessary for remote access.
Can Yale and Schlage be keyed alike?
Inherently, Schlage and Yale come with different keyways. However, they can be keyed alike if you replace their cylinders, using interchangeable cores or asking a locksmith’s consultation for customized solutions.
Can the Yale Assure Lock 2 be used without a smart home hub?
Yes, the Yale Assure Lock 2 is Bluetooth-enabled right out of the box; however, a Wi-Fi module or smart home hub is needed for integrations and remote access.
How long do the batteries last in both locks?
With Wi-Fi, the Schlage Encode Plus lasts for roughly six months. With Bluetooth, the Yale Assure Lock 2 has a one-year battery life; with a Wi-Fi module, it lasts six months.
Can you add multiple users to these locks?
Yes, multiple user codes are supported for both locks. The Yale Assure Lock 2 can support up to 250 codes, while the Schlage Encode Plus can support up to 100.
